Tuesday, October 18, 2005

You Give National Schools A Bad Name!

Thanks to reader, John Lee for his link to this particular blog post by Cik Amoi a week ago. In the post entitled "Misguided HM in National School", Cik Amoi gave an example of the poor administration of the national schools which if not checked, will further polarise, the race community in Malaysia. Below are some excerpts from her post, whereby Cik Amoi's 'friend's daughter' was enrolled into the national secondary school (Sekolah Menengah Kebangsaan).
In her first year (Form 1), she made many friends from all races and was very happy in that school. In fact, one of her best friend is a Malay girl whose father is also a school teacher, albeit in another district. My friend's daughter did very well in her school exams and came out among the top 3 in her class. However, for some unexplained reasons, she was "demoted" and separated from the class of best students in her second year. She ended up in a class of students who are more interested in disrupting the teachers and playing the fool rather than doing any actual learning.

In her second year, she applied for leave from school to sit for her Piano ABRSM theory examination which happened to clash with the day she was to sit for a Sejarah test paper. She was told to see the HM regarding the matter. Imagine her shock when the HM refused to even listen to her plea or even look at the proof of exam attendance slip. Instead, the headmistress refused to look at her, waved her off with her hand and curtly dismissed her with a "ini semua alasan saja. Kalau kamu absent, kamu dapat markah kosonglah." With that, she was summarily dismissed from the office. Needless to say, she was almost in tears.

My friend was shocked by the callous attitude of the headmistress and went to the school the next morning to try to explain the situation to her. However, the HM was out of the office on "personal matters" and he was attended to by the asst HM. When he showed the exam slip to her, she retorted with a "Oh, ini untuk ujian Piano. Anak kamu dari keluarga elit, ya?. Maaf, saya tak boleh tolong. Kalau alasan tak mahu datang sekolah kerana sakit masuk hospital atau saudara mati, itu boleh. Lain alasan mesti tanya guru besar dulu. Datanglah besok pagi" My friend was utterly speechless!!

When he finally caught up with the HM, she was in a better mood. The HM conceded that it is not possible for the girl to change her Piano exam date and agreed to allow her to sit for the Sejarah paper in her office immediately after she finished her Piano test. When my friend queried her on why she refused to give her consideration to the request earlier, he was further shocked by her reply that it was because there are so many other students in the school who frequently apply for leave to attend "Church" matters (hal-hal agama Kristian)! She thought that my friend's daughter was also trying to skip school to attend "Church". Maybe it was the HM's good fortune that my friend is not a Christian, otherwise, he would be HUGELY OFFENDED by her remark.
Is there a HOTLINE which we can call the Ministry of Education and complain about the headmistress and assistant headmistress? I'm in agreement with Cik Amoi that the above experience is not unique, and is prevalent in many schools throughout the country. At the same time, I'm aware that there are also excellent head of schools in Malaysia and these black sheeps just give national schools, which is the critical melting pot to promote national integration, a terrible name.

The problem is, in the best case scenario, the headmistress gets transferred to another school as "punishment". To me that's not punishment for the headmistress, but instead for the poor students of this other school, at the continued expense of the taxpayers.

There's clearly plenty to be "transformed" and improved about our education system, and our team of teachers and education administrators. Things will not change overnight - not a chance. But if things do improve bit by bit over time, then that's worth fighting for the future generation of young Malaysians. The question is, where do we start?

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

Where do we start?

As I commented in the Rais Yatim post, deal with the liveware (the people) first and foremost.

The thinking and the attitudes. That's the crux of the problem.

How? Frankly, don't know how to get through to them. Any suggestions?

Bigjoe99 said...

On the surface, the problem seems to be prejudice but if you think about it, its not just that. Its actually sheer mediocrity. The HM inconsistencies is just a case of not having an actual thinking mind. Any adult worth his salt knows that to assume is to make an ass of oneself not to mention and HM. The mediocrity pervades our entire education system and hold back thousand of children every year. From the primary schools all up to the top ministry level and universities, a prevalence of mediocrity is our national achilles heel.

rakyat said...

Could this be only an isolated incident?

flywithme said...

The root of all these mess (from education, poverty and corruption) the country is in now mainly due to the 'Ketuanan Melayu' metality in Malay mind. Thats all I can say.

Anonymous said...

This is ridiculous. I remembered my friends all taking their piano test and having no problem at all with it.

I think it's worse that today school or people are becoming more and more racist.It should be the opposite since government is promoting more unity.

Anonymous said...

When the Policy makers are racists, the down lines are certainly the same. That is why those being racism never got the deserved punishment.
Don't tell us the Policy makers are not racists, you can judge very clearly from their comments at different gatherings.
States in Borneo were invited to form a Malaysia, but the people are losing what they were having before, especially the educational chances. Do the Ministry dare to clarify how many of the excellence from Borneo have placement with their choices justly?
Hornbill

Anonymous said...

I learned that Students are still waiting for the result for the entrance to the Public Universities after appealing made by the due date of 24/8/2011. I don't understand why, can anybody solve my puzzle?
My only knowledge for the delay is the Total Inefficiency of the Government which lead to the Ministry's disgusting inefficiency.
Quite many of them who are waiting for the outcome are still wondering if they should accept the offer form the private universities, or even the oversea universities.

I have just read from news that student of 2011 A Level with "2A*" and "2A", I suppose this is equivalent to the STPM "2A" & "2A-", were accepted with Medicine study. How can this be, while many of the STPM 2010 applied for Dental, Pharmacy, Chemical Engineering where not even given any course!!