Monday, August 29, 2005

“Malaysia's Races Live Peacefully -- But Separately”

In an aptly titled article “Malaysia’s races live peacefully – but separately” published by AFP on today, probably in conjunction with Malaysia celebrating its National Day in a few days’ time, it summarises the racial environment in the country.

While racial relations isn’t exactly the subject of this blog, the article highlights some of the key factors why our race relations environment is in the state it is – our education system.
Separate schools, separate friends, separate social lives -- Malaysia marks 48 years of independence Wednesday but many citizens lament the lack of ties between majority Malays and the Chinese and Indians living alongside them.
Racial integration has to start young, and that has to be in our primary and secondary schools. There was a time in the 1970s and early 1980s whereby Chinese parents were sending their children to national type schools in significant numbers. My parents sent me to a national type ex-missionary school in Batu Pahat because I will get to learn the English language which my parents are unable to teach me. They also saw the national type school as a way enable me to mix with non-Chinese students as we do live in multi-racial Malaysia after all.

However, these same students who have enrolled and graduated from the national type schools are today sending their own children to the typically overcrowded Chinese vernacular schools for various reasons I’ve blogged here and here. The resultant impact is epitomised by 24-year-old ethnic Chinese Kathleen Chong, a recent graduate of the University Putra Malaysia quoted in the article.
…it pains her to see the widespread racial polarisation on campus -- a microcosm of the national picture. "The various races only mix among themselves. There is very little interaction," she says. "Please, let us enjoy true racial unity in Malaysia. We need to stop the growing tide of division."

Chong admits that she too stuck with her Chinese friends for classes, activities and meals. "This is what every other race does in the campus."
The above scenario is not at all surprising for I see the results of the above segregation in my very own office. There is little or no mixing between, particularly the Chinese educated and the Malays / Indians. I’m concerned because should the situation persist, then our education system today will actually result in the dismantling of whatever inter-racial social structure that existed before the ensure all ethnic groups live in harmony. The harmony we enjoy today is the fruits of labour of our founding fathers and the segregation we see today will result in the likely disintegration of the harmony in the future.

I’m thankful that all is not lost, for our current Prime Minister appears to be aware of the negative circumstances and is putting effort (against resistance from various vested interest parties) in overcoming the problem. The “Rancangan Integrasi Murid Untuk Perpaduan” (RIMUP) is one such example. The president of Parti Gerakan Rakyat Malaysia appears also to have found the voice to promote the concept of Anak Malaysia. And there are also those even within the UMNO ruling party, such as Hilmi Abdul Rashid, a state assemblyman with Penang who agrees that the lack of interaction between the various racial groups “is a serious problem”.
"The young generation are not mixing as much as the older generation. I am worried now. We need to address the issue immediately."
As rightly pointed out by the article, the problems lies, contrary to popular opinion, not only with our government authorities but also with the mindset of many vernacular school educationist, who in my opinion, are overly defensive over the “rights” to Chinese education.
Education and language is one of the most visible signs of the problem. Most Chinese and Indians send their children to Mandarin- and Tamil-language schools while the Malays attend national institutions.

The government has in recent years established "visionary schools" where students share sports fields, assembly halls and canteens, but conduct classes in their own languages. But the initiative has failed to get off the ground, partly because of a fear of a loss of identity among Chinese.
It is imperative that the government set its priorities right – not just in the micro measures (such as RIMUP) but also address the macro issues which the minority communities have been voicing out over the years, in particular the overly extensive use of positive discrimination to the significant disadvantage of the other racial communities. At the same time, the vernacular school educationists need to see the light that continued segregation in the education system for our Malaysian young is leading the country towards the path that no community will ever want to thread upon.

8 comments:

meiteoh said...

I think it has everything to do with the home FIRST before the education system. The attitude that our parents encourages us to grow, our perspective on race is all based on our parent's behaviour.

Chances are if your parents never had friends from another race, you won't see the point in doing so.

I was lucky. My dad visited his Malay and Indian friends ALL the time. And we're Chinese.

I went to a national school here in PJ and my best friends were Indians and Malays. I learnt to write in Malay first before I had even learnt to speak/write fluent English. In secondary school, my best buddy was a Malay girl. When I was in college, I hung around a Maldivian, and Malay lady (she was the oldest in our class) most of the time.

I was never stuck to just Chinese because lets face the facts, we are Malaysians first before anything else - or at least I think so.

If anything, we should re-educate our would-be daddies and mummies out there that kids are often follow in their parent's footsteps - like it or not. Check out some socialization theories (on the self). :)

Bigjoe99 said...

No one can argue with the idealism here but the criticism of vernacular educationist I believe is unfair. I am not big fan of too much vernacular education but these people are defending a cause in a tough environment. The cause of vernacular school is not only vernacular education but also about non-bumi right to self-determination in education and hence life. They have taken a hard line because their opponent have taken a hard line. They are in a weaker position so giving up any ground is dangerous for them. Yes sometimes they have taken position that is not positive and has negatives but the tall order they are defending justify that. The government refusal to allocate more schools for Chinese primary school is an exercise in hegemony and not rational thinking. Its the destruction of others for inability and refusal to look at one owns weakness and failures. The government just cannot be trusted with these issues and you should know better.

rakyat said...

I agree with Bigjoe99. If nothing is done, eventually you lose even your right to learn your mother-tongue. There are already no vernacular secondary schools. Only a handful of primary schools remain.

The report below on the state of our education system by the Johore Bar is an eye opener.

http://www.johorebar.org.my/content/view/102/27/

malaysia is low class said...

Umno, which effectively runs the government, is riddled with corruption and croynism.

Members crave for the award of lucrative government contracts given out under the pretext of the NEP. But the party is filled with bureaucrats with no management skills and no productive economic skills.

In a freely competitive market, they would be in the lower rungs of the public sector or would have lost their jobs altogether. To maintain their way of life, they have to ensure that the NEP is continued at all costs.

A large segment of the malays are still poor after 35 years of the NEP and on top of this the income disparity between the rich and the poor has widened. Clearly, the NEP as a method of equalising economic disparity has failed.

The benefits of the NEP to the poor malay is a pittance compared to the benefits to the rich and well-connected malay. It is in reality a tool and facade for the rich and elite malays - who are in the minority - to continue their extravagant way of life at the expense of the rest of the country.

The cost of the NEP so far include unemployable graduates who are mostly malay, increased racial polarisation, declining education standards, brain drain, bailouts of well-connected companies, an inefficient and incompetent public service, a government which makes decisions first and studies the impact later - just about everything that is wrong in this country!

no brain leader said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
racist man said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
jump the ship said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
malaysia is no future said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.